Skip to content
PeluvaReviewsShop Peluva

Women's Carrie ST Reviews — page 2

What verified buyers say about the Women's Carrie ST — comfort, fit, durability and how it compares to conventional shoes.

4.6

41 verified reviews

90% rated 4 stars or higher

5 star30
4 star7
3 star3
2 star1
1 star0

41 Women's Carrie ST reviews

Verified Buyer

Ms. Neta Miller

I did step aerobics in my shoes ( 1 st. time wearing them) normally I wear a knee brace but didn’t wear one with my new Peluva’s my back and knee felt normal .

Customer photo of Women's Carrie ST
Waneta D.· June 21, 2025

Response from Peluva

That’s amazing, Ms. Neta! We’re thrilled to hear your first step aerobics session in your new Peluvas went so well—especially without needing your usual knee brace. Stories like yours inspire us. Keep moving strong!

Verified Buyer

Love these

I felt better foot function and better awareness of the ground while wearing them

Wendy C.· June 2, 2025

Response from Peluva

We’re so glad they are helping you feel more connected and supported, Wendy! That’s exactly what we aim for with every step.

Verified Buyer

Toe Shoes

The Carries are so cute. The only problem I had is they run really small. I gave them to my niece and she loves them. I hope to order me another pair soon.

Bonnie G.· April 28, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thanks for the kind words, Bonnie! We're glad your niece is loving them. For your next pair, we recommend going up a half size for a better fit. Feel free to email support@peluva.com if you need any help!

Verified Buyer

Love them!

They are so comfortable!

Karyn B.· March 14, 2025

Response from Peluva

Glad to hear you're loving the Carrie ST, Karyn! Comfort is what we aim for. Thanks for your support!

Verified Buyer

Carrie st-Women

Love these shoes!!! I ordered some for my husband!! They feel amazing

Customer photo of Women's Carrie ST
Kevin R.· August 18, 2024
Customer Review

3 Stars

You send me a size Levin. They do not fit. I need a 12, thank you. Could you send me a return slip? So I can send them out to you.

Teresa· May 18, 2024
Verified Buyer

Great for wide feet! Best -fitting Peluva Shoe!

The strands were too tight on the top of my foot, and the footbed was a little narrow. These soles are nearly the same width, however the Carrie is more forgiving for wider feet. Many people complained the uppers are too loose, but they are perfect for my foot shape. The stretch is great, and I’m maybe 20 hours of wear in, but I love it! These need more widths and a restock!! The free socks are ok but not worth buying on their own. Also, I would highly recommend socks with these for more than a few minutes of wear. I started to get blisters.

Customer photo of Women's Carrie STCustomer photo of Women's Carrie STCustomer photo of Women's Carrie ST
Molly F.· May 13, 2024
Verified Buyer

Like them

Super like them

Mary Lou H.· May 10, 2024
Verified Buyer

Took a little getting used to, but really nice

They're very comfortable and fit me perfectly. More color options would be great, but I can't complain. These look good, and feel good.

Blade S.· May 6, 2024
Verified Buyer

Love em

Most comfortable shoe I’ve ever put on my feet!

Elizabeth K.· March 27, 2024
Verified Buyer

Comfy and well to adjust to

Super easy to adjust to, only issue is with my work they got dirty quick 😔. But I’ve gotten many complements on them!

VADA B.· March 22, 2024
Verified Buyer

Good walking shoe

I have a pair of Strands that I like very much. I wear those without socks. I like these Carries too. I wore them once with socks and once without. Prefer these with socks. Nice looking too. Good shade of blue.

debra· March 19, 2024
Customer Review

3 Stars

Came late and they forgot the toe socks. fits great and very excited!!

Euphrates· March 7, 2024
Verified Buyer

Great Shoe!

I have significant damage to my feet from accidents/falls + I have bad back & knees. These are helping correct some of my issues. 🥰

Lisa B.· February 15, 2024
Verified Buyer

Comffy

Verrrry satisfied with them. With or without socks.

Karen G.· January 29, 2024
Verified Buyer

Perfect - right out of the box!

Only took two tries to figure out how to work with the socks and shoes. The fit is amazing. Ironically, I did the foot scan for the Strand pair and they are too small. But these fit like a glove. I think I will like the full loop for getting them on vs. the little tab on the Strand model. I'm just deciding which second pair I want! It will be a while until I can try them outside (it's January in Wisconsin), but I'll be wearing the Carrie model inside the gym tomorrow.

Mary A.· January 15, 2024
Verified Buyer

Beautiful but really loose

I was incredibly excited for these shoes because of how sleek and modern they looked compared to all the Vibram Five Fingers shoes I have. I am no stranger to toe shoes and in fact love them. I have been looking for other brands that make toe shoes for a while now when I came across Peluva. But this specific Carrie ST model was let down. Since the top is laceless I was expecting them to be tight fitting and stretchy. But instead they are incredibly loose and stretchy. I can comfortably fit 4 of my fingers in the shoe along with my foot. So needless to say my foot moves around a lot when trying to walk in them. The shoes fit length wise so I cannot size down. I honestly don't know if these shoes would fit anyone who doesn't have swollen feet or very tall and wide feet. I should also note that my husband tried the men's Napa Dress Trainer (which is sadly not available in women's sizes) and didn't have this issue because those shoes have laces and can be manually adjusted. I would give 5 stars for the sleek and modern color block aesthetics of these shoes but I have to give 1 star for the fact that they are too loose and my feet move up and down with every step. Overall 3 stars. Peluva if you can modify this design in future releases to be tighter and still a stretchy slip on, I would love to give them another shot. Also I would absolutely love to see these shoes in a sage green or mint green colorway!

Customer photo of Women's Carrie STCustomer photo of Women's Carrie ST
Laura M.· January 14, 2024

Reviews for other Peluva models