Skip to content
PeluvaReviewsShop Peluva

Men's Strand ATR Reviews — page 12

What verified buyers say about the Men's Strand ATR — comfort, fit, durability and how it compares to conventional shoes.

4.8

581 verified reviews

97% rated 4 stars or higher

5 star501
4 star60
3 star12
2 star3
1 star5

581 Men's Strand ATR reviews

Verified Buyer

Great so far!

I had to exchange my first pair to go down one size, and the new pair fits well. These shoes are comfortable right out of the box. The build quality appears to be good. The look of the shoes is cool! I look forward to hiking in them soon, to really test them out. Do far, so good. I like them!

Eric O.· December 22, 2025

Response from Peluva

Glad to hear the new size fits well, Eric! Sounds like you’re off to a great start, hope they perform just as well out on the trails.

Verified Buyer

👌🏽

♥️

Matthew C.· December 21, 2025
Verified Buyer

Honestly the best show I have owned.

I have very wide feet and have nevwr found shoes comfortable. I can wear these all day long with no discomfort. Absolutely love them

Joe D.· December 21, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thanks for the love, Joe! We’re so glad the Strand ATRs are delivering all-day comfort, especially for your wide feet. That kind of fit is exactly what we aim for. Keep enjoying them!

Verified Buyer

If you have a bunion and LONG second toe, read this!

I am amazed! This is the only shoe that I can wear all day long not not have my bunion feel like it is going to explode - check out the ugly picture! The history about my cramped toes and bunion: I ran track through college and jammed my feet into very tight track spikes, then spent 38 years in small toe box dress shoes (I was a CEO), and now play tennis using shoes that don't help the situation. On top of that, I have the long second toes that make every shoe fit problematic. On longer! I have had the strand atr for 4 days and have had zero issues. I'm a size 9 and ordered a 9.5 along with the socks (I'm now using toe socks with my tennis shoes). The long toe has a little space and at first I thought it was rubbing against the edge while walking, but that is starting to go away as I wear the shoe. The other toes have a good gap, so ordering a 10 might be too much. Most of what I am feeling is the toe actually doing its job on the surface of the ground, which is something you might have to get used to. For kicks, I did a few sprinting bursts and felt like I could run 10.1 in the 100 again! I wear them around the house, for walks, and working out. What are the downsides? 1) Getting used to how to put them on. By day 2, I figured out that if I WIGGLED MY TOES while sliding my foot on, the toes find the slots much easier. 2) Deciding whether to go a half size larger or one size larger regarding the toe fit. There is some contradictory info on the website about fit - one section recommends half a size larger, and the shoe-specific section indicates one size larger. This causes a lot of second-guessing what to order, i.e., at first I wanted to return for size 10, but gave it time and decided to keep the 9.5. Overall, I wear these things all the time now (except on the tennis court - but if Mark wants to send me a free tennis version, I'll play test them!). My wife thinks they look wierd but is putting up with them in public! They call me the "Flash" and now, because of the way the shoe looks, I am officially the Tiger Flash!

A bare foot on concrete pavementA pair of feet wearing white toe socks with individual toe compartments, resting on a stone surfaceA pair of gray toe shoes with individual finger compartments and blue laces, worn on feet in red pants, photographed on a wooden floor with a map visible in the backgroundA light blue athletic running shoe with dark blue accents and orange details, worn with a red sock, photographed on a wooden floor
Len· December 20, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thank you, Len! Your feedback is incredibly helpful. We’re thrilled the Strand ATRs are easing your bunion discomfort and working well for your long second toe. We’re taking note of your sizing concerns and your awesome tips for getting them on. Love your “Tiger Flash” nickname, we’re cheering you on!

Verified Buyer

Great shoes!

These shoes are super comfortable. My feet can spread out nice and easy.

Kirk M.· December 19, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thanks, Kirk! We’re glad to hear you’re enjoying the comfort and natural toe spread of your Strand ATRs. That’s exactly what we designed them for, happy training!

Verified Buyer

Love them

Fantastic for outdoor hiking and trail walking.

Person's leg and foot visible while walking on a paved path through tropical vegetation with palm trees and lush greenery on both sides
Patrick S.· December 19, 2025

Response from Peluva

Glad to hear it, Patrick! Thanks for taking your Peluvas out on the trails sounds like they’re doing exactly what we designed them for.

Verified Buyer

After 10 plus years I am over Vibrams

I bought into toe shoes like Five Finger Vibrams because of the ability to mobilize my toes and strengthen my feet. PELUVAS felt great out of the box. These shoes dont strangle my feet, provides better protection, and provide far more energy return .

Person wearing black toe shoes standing on asphalt pavement
Jerry N.· December 19, 2025

Response from Peluva

Appreciate you sharing your experience, Jerry. It’s awesome to hear you’ve made the switch and are enjoying the extra comfort and energy return. We’re honored to be your new go-to!

Customer Review

5 Stars

High-quality, highly recommended.

Steven· December 19, 2025
Verified Buyer

5 Stars

High-quality, highly recommended.

Steven· December 19, 2025
Verified Buyer

Love my Peluva's

I've had a pair of Vibrams for over 7 Years which I love. I decided to try the Peluva's. Very comparative and for me the Peluva's are slightly more comfortable. So far so good!! I'm considering trying the court shoes and would love input from you all to get your opinion on how they hold up/perform for pickleball.

Jeffrey S.· December 18, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thanks for the great feedback, Jeffrey! We’re thrilled to hear you’re enjoying your Peluvas compared to your Vibrams. We’ll pass along your interest in the court shoes for pickleball, stay tuned, and we appreciate your support!

Verified Buyer

Mens Strand ATR Black

Never really done reviews like this before so I'm just going to give straight facts and experience with these. They are an excellent tool once you get use to them and learn how to walk a different way with them. If you go full bore into these and do trail walking on rough terrain like I did, you are going to have some aches and pains from using muscles and tendons more than they are usually used. Have over 30 miles between these and Vibram's with a backpack on rough terrain. These are my go-to now cause at 250 lbs. you want the extra cushion, so you don't bruise your heels or something else. Long in short, after you form to them walking and adjust, I walk better and stronger. My legs are physically stronger from just using them. I had a pop in my knee from cartilage, and it seems to have gone away for the most part. Calves seem stronger and have more motor control over the tendons and muscles in the feet. They do get stronger because you start naturally using what's there for more stabilizing and proprioception. They are an awesome tool and do what they are supposed to do for me. Sometimes wearing normal all terrain sneaker seems foreign, and you can tell it handicaps movement. Sizing for men's 13 for me was slightly snug but then when they wear in a little it's right where you want it. If you wear them in public, yeah you might get some looks and stares but it's because it's just something that's not normal in their eyes and don't see much but to each their own. Who cares. Maybe the way we do things needs to be rethought, and this is one thing Peluva has done. Just my opinion.

Clifford E.· December 18, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thank you, Clifford, this is an incredible review! We’re glad the shoes are helping with strength, alignment, and comfort, especially on rugged terrain. Your insights on the adjustment period and long-term benefits are invaluable for others considering the transition.

Verified Buyer

New Customer

I'm 62 yrs old and developed minor foot issues. Viewed a brief video online & was intrigued. Purchased a pair of Strand ATR's for indoor workouts and really like them so far. I wear them everyday, toe separation feels great, and support is good (so far). For me a full size from normal was too much, half size larger was fine, and return & exchange process was top notch!

Anthony W.· December 18, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thank you for sharing your experience, Anthony! We’re happy to hear the toe separation and support are working well for your workouts. Great insight on sizing too—glad the half-size up was the sweet spot!

Verified Buyer

My favorite Peluva shoes, and now in Black!

These are my favorite Peluva shoes, I had two pair but when the black ones became available I ordered another. I like having a bit more "grip" on the bottom, and I LOVE the new lacing system. I've got almost every different design of Peluva shoes (for men) so I can evaluate the different models under various conditions.

William S.· December 17, 2025

Response from Peluva

Awesome to hear, William! Glad you’re enjoying the extra grip and updated lacing. Your detailed comparisons are incredibly valuable.

Verified Buyer

Game changer

These are awesome. I’ve been wearing them everyday since I got them! No issues! A little expensive but well worth it. Just make sure you buy half a size up for socks and shoes as they recommend.

Dakota S.· December 16, 2025

Response from Peluva

We appreciate the review, Dakota. It’s awesome to hear the shoes are making a difference. Thanks for pointing out the sizing tip, super helpful for others!

Verified Buyer

Solid

Better than a different brand I tried

Darren J.· December 16, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thanks for the comparison, Darren! We’re glad to hear Peluva stands out for you.

Verified Buyer

Best barefoot shoe I've tried

As a former owner of Vibrams, Vivobarefoot, and Xero shoes, these are the best for me.

Albert C.· December 15, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thank you, Albert! We’re thrilled to hear our shoes are your favorite among other top barefoot brands. Enjoy your hikes and that natural feel - we appreciate you being part of the Peluva community!

Verified Buyer

2nd pair

I love these! I saw people say how comfortable they were. My first pair I did not size up. They were a bit to snug. I got these a half size up and they fit perfectly. I see what people mean when they say these are the most comfortable shoes they have worn! My feet are feeling better, no more blisters, cuts and sore arches and heals!

John M.· December 15, 2025

Response from Peluva

So glad the second pair was the perfect fit, John. It’s great to hear your feet are feeling better—no more blisters or sore arches is a win in our book!

Verified Buyer

Superb Tennis Shoe

I’m currently recovering from a stroke and am about 6 months into my recovery. The Men’s Strand ATR shoes have been a game-changer for me. They provide great stability and support, and I genuinely feel more confident and balanced when walking. Since wearing them, my gait feels smoother and my overall walking has improved. Comfortable, well-made, and truly helpful during my recovery. Highly recommend.

Person wearing black toe shoes and jeans standing on beige tile flooring
Stuart R.· December 15, 2025

Response from Peluva

Thank you for sharing this, Stuart. We’re honored our shoes have helped support your recovery. Wishing you continued strength and progress!

Verified Buyer

Amazing

Most comfortable shoe I’ve ever owned. Worth the extra minutes it takes to put them on.

Jeffrey F.· December 15, 2025

Response from Peluva

So glad to hear it, Jeffrey. Thanks for sticking with the extra effort to put them on. That comfort sounds well worth it!

Verified Buyer

Feel different

Feel great just got to get used to feeling free toes being exposed to new freedom

Black toe shoes with textured soles on wooden floorBlack toe shoe with individual toe compartments and laces on wooden surfaceBlack athletic shoe with lacing system on wooden floorA pair of black toe shoes with individual toe compartments placed on a wooden floor surface
Charles S.· December 12, 2025

Response from Peluva

Appreciate the feedback, Charles. It definitely takes a little time to adjust, but once you do, that toe freedom is a game changer! Thanks for giving them a try.

Verified Buyer

Much more comfortable than I thought!

Honestly, I would like to see a future design where the toes are covered, but still separated underneath. That's just a style thing, though. Overall these shoes have been a game changer for me. I love Mark Sisson and anything he puts his name on, I know I can trust. That man has changed my life in so many ways. Thanks for doing this! Looking forward to where it goes from here.

Jeffrey H.· December 12, 2025

Response from Peluva

Appreciate the thoughtful feedback, Jeffrey. Great idea on the style tweak. We’re thrilled the shoes are making such a positive impact for you!

Verified Buyer

5 Stars

Absolutely wonderful

Jazzy· December 11, 2025
Customer Review

5 Stars

Absolutely wonderful

Jazzy· December 11, 2025
Verified Buyer

New favorite shoe.

I've been using the shoe for walking, hiking, and for any opportunity to wear them. The shoe is so light and comfortable to wear for running errands. It's taken some time to be able to "slip" them on without having to push and pull my toes into their appropriate toe sleeves but once on it's great. I've noticed that my feet, though sore after a 10+ mile walk/hike it is nothing like when I was wearing traditional shoes like New Balance or Salomons as well as a pair of water shoes that were OK but not as comfortable for long walks. I now have two pair of Peluvas, one Strand and now my Strand ATR.

Robert A. S.· December 11, 2025

Response from Peluva

Robert, it’s great to hear how well the Strand ATR is working for your active lifestyle. That comfort on long hikes is exactly what we aim for. Thanks for sharing the comparison with your previous footwear too, very helpful!

Reviews for other Peluva models